Caucus meetings

A caucus meeting is a form of pre-hearing meeting with a similar aim – to discuss and resolve differences before the hearing process begins. However, the participants in a caucus meetings are experts who have prepared or will prepare expert evidence to present to the hearing panel.

What is the purpose of a caucus meeting?

The caucus system allows experts to consult with each other, and attempt to understand their respective positions on the subject matter and look for common ground.

What can a caucus meeting achieve?

This process provides an opportunity to clarify misunderstandings, but also it assists the hearing panel to understand what the points of agreement and disagreement are between experts.

How does a caucus meeting operate?

Experts will meet – sometimes with an independent facilitator who will mediate and run the meeting. Generally the meeting will focus on the expert evidence that has been presented and each expert will have the opportunity to discuss points of each others evidence which they agree or disagree with.

Remember that during the discussion experts are expected to give their opinion.

Experts should not:

  • act as an advocate for their organisation
  • refer back to their organisation. An expert witness is there to express their expert opinion not their organisations opinion.

What is the outcome from a caucus meeting?

The experts [sometimes with help from a facilitator] will produce an agreed statement that identifies their areas of agreement, areas of disagreement and the reasons for disagreement. After the meeting a draft is then circulated to participants who are given an opportunity to review the statement before it is given to the hearing panel.

Who can attend a caucus meeting?

Submitters with expertise who will present expert evidence in support of their own submission

  • Independent experts who will present expert evidence of behalf of a submitter.
  • In the case of the Proposed One Plan hearings, council officers and consultants who will also be presenting expert evidence.
  • Possibly an independent facilitator.

To view a PDF of the caucsing factsheet please click here